Margaritaville at Sea Islander 2024 Updated Review + Cruise News [Podcast]

Doug Parker discusses recent cruise news with staff writer Richard Simms. Richard covered a landslide in Ketchikan, Alaska, which caused damage and casualties but did not directly affect cruise passengers.

Large cruise ship named "Norwegian Getaway" sailing in clear blue waters under a partly cloudy sky, adorned with colorful artwork featuring palm trees and ocean scenes—perfect for fans of Margaritaville at Sea.
(Photo courtesy of Margaritaville at Sea)

He also addresses ongoing propulsion issues with the Carnival Vista, itinerary changes, and Royal Caribbean’s plans for new mega-ships. Additionally, Richard reports on travel chaos in Seattle due to a cyberattack, arrests for credit card fraud at Port Miami, and the delayed launch of the Villa Odyssey.

Doug then interviews guest Mitch, who shares his experiences from a recent cruise on the Margaritaville at Sea Islander. Mitch describes a cumbersome embarkation process, mixed dining experiences, and vibrant onboard entertainment.

He highlights the ship’s Margaritaville theme, noting positives and improvement areas. Mitch also recounts excursions in Key West and Nassau, emphasizing the need for better coordination and amenities for cruise passengers.

Overall, he finds the cruise enjoyable but suggests enhancements for a smoother experience.

This episode is brought to you by TripInsurance.com, giving you three levels of travel protection — Good, Better, and Best — a travel insurance policy for every budget.
Margaritaville at Sea Islander
(Photo courtesy of Margaritaville at Sea)
Listen to the episode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, or where you listen to your favorite podcast.

Timestamps:

  • Landslide in Alaska (00:00:41): Discussion of a landslide in Ketchikan, Alaska, causing injuries but no cruise passenger involvement.
  • Carnival Vista’s Propulsion Issues (00:02:07): Update on ongoing propulsion issues with Carnival Vista and itinerary changes for upcoming sailings.
  • New Mega Ships from Royal Caribbean (00:03:55): Announce new Icon class ships from Royal Caribbean, including themed supper clubs.
  • Cyber Attack in Seattle (00:06:11): Details on a cyber attack disrupting flights and baggage claims at Seattle airport.
  • Credit Card Fraud Arrests at Port Miami (00:07:40): Four individuals were arrested for using stolen credit cards at a casino on MSC Magnifica.
  • Update on the Villa Odyssey (00:09:37): Status of the Villa Odyssey, allowing guests aboard but requiring them to stay in hotels.
  • Margaritaville at Sea Islander Review (00:13:20): Mitch shares his experiences aboard the Margaritaville at Sea Islander, including the embarkation process.
  • Embarkation Process (00:15:53): Mitch describes the security and check-in process, noting it was slow and laborious.
  • First Impressions of the Ship (00:17:05): Mitch is excited about the Margaritaville-themed decor and unique lobby design.
  • Stateroom Experience (00:17:48): Mitch compares his interior room to the Margaritaville hotel with bright, themed decor.
  • Storage Availability (00:18:40): He mentions limited storage in the cabin, making it challenging for three guests over five nights.
  • Buffet Area Overview (00:19:24): Mitch introduces the buffet area, called “the port of indecision,” and discusses its setup and lines.
  • Food Quality and Service Issues (00:20:51): Mitch expresses disappointment with the food quality and scheduling gaps in dining options.
  • Complimentary Pizza and Burger Options (00:22:26): He describes the complimentary pizza and burger options, noting long lines during peak times.
  • Specialty Restaurants (00:23:46): Mitch mentions a steakhouse experience shared by another guest, highlighting its positive reviews.
  • Main Dining Room Experience (00:24:33): He discusses the mixed dining experiences, including long wait times and friendly staff.
  • Entertainment Options (00:27:05): Mitch describes the entertainment atmosphere, noting the quality of music and limited theater shows.
  • Crowd Management and Pool Layout (00:29:00): He shares thoughts on pool areas, noting crowd dynamics and preferences for pool versus hot tub.
  • Cruising Experience and Guest Demographics (00:31:10): Mitch reflects on the mix of seasoned cruisers and newcomers, particularly Jimmy Buffett fans.
  • Day in Key West (00:32:35): Mitch prepares to discuss his experience in Key West, hinting at what was memorable.
  • Getting Off the Ship (00:32:36): He describes a challenging disembarkation experience due to delays and crowding.
  • Jet Ski Tour Experience (00:33:06): After disembarking, Mitch shares his enjoyment of a privately booked jet ski tour.
  • Nassau Visit Overview (00:34:05): Mitch discusses the short time spent in Nassau and the late arrival.
  • Exploring Nassau’s new port area (00:35:13): He appreciates the area’s layout and accessibility.
  • Jenkins Beach Visit (00:35:53): Mitch talks about visiting Jenkins Beach and suggests shared privileges with the Margaritaville Hotel.
  • Casino Experience (00:38:04): Mitch mentions his casino experience, noting he didn’t notice smoke and played slots.
  • Demarcation Process (00:38:29): Mitch describes a smooth demarcation process and a quick return home.
  • First-Time Tips for Cruisers (00:39:11): Mitch advises bringing a watch due to the lack of functioning clocks on the ship.
  • Room Key Concerns (00:40:02): He raises safety concerns about room keys displaying room numbers.
  • Cruise Highlights (00:40:53): Mitch reflects on the enjoyable theme and staff of the cruise.
  • Survey Feedback (00:41:40): Mitch discusses the crew’s emphasis on completing surveys during the cruise.
  • Final Thoughts on Margaritaville at Sea (00:42:18): If the price is right, Mitch recommends the cruise for Buffett fans and first-time cruisers.
  • Craft Cocktails on Board (00:42:52): Mitch mentions a craft cocktail bar called Havana Daydreaming as a highlight for unique drinks.