A union pier-side protest against Carnival Australia’s treatment of crew members has been criticized, and it’s not just from the cruise operator.
There was also some pushback from the crew themselves. In a mixed reaction, it was suggested the Maritime Union of Australia’s protest aim was more about increasing union membership than pushing for better pay and conditions.
Union protest criticized by some crew members
Some also said the union hasn’t spoken to them about working conditions. One added that the union’s aims were unrealistic. “They’re comparing Australian standards to international maritime contracts.”
“Carnival Cruises is paying its crew as little as $2.50 an hour to work on its Australian cruise ships. This has got to be the worst labor exploitation we have ever seen, and it’s happening in plain sight,” said union organizer Shane Reside.
“When companies like Carnival behave like this, it casts a cloud over all of us. We will not stop until this ugly exploitation is stamped out for good.” Reside said the union has detailed its grievances, but Carnival management refuses to negotiate in good faith.
The protest at Station Pier in Melbourne attracted about 100 people. Carnival has three ships based in Australia.
The cruise company hit back, calling the demonstration a ‘lame tactic’ and nothing more than a recruitment drive for union membership.
“Let’s call the Maritime Union of Australia (MUA) activity for what it is: to increase membership and raise revenue. They don’t care about our employees except to try to get a portion of their paycheck for their treasury,” it said ahead of the protest.
“This so-called campaign is offensive to the dedicated shipboard team members who take pride in their work.”
The union claims Carnival “exploits a loophole in the Coastal Trading Act,” while the company responded that it “meets, and in most cases exceeds” what is require under the Maritime Labour Convention.
